Mexican Fideicomisos and Filing Forms 3520 and 3520A each year.

In Mexico Fideicomisos hold title to  certain real property owned  by non-Mexicans citizens. A Mexican bank is designated as the Trustee and the wording of the Fideicomiso document is clearly that of a trust.  The IRS has never made a written pronouncement or ruling that excludes Fideicomisos from the requirement that they file annually  Forms 3520 and 3520A.  Penalties for not filing these forms or filing them late are huge and can be up to 15% of the value of the property in the trust.

A Texas attorney recently has been widely circulating a  written opinion she wrote and a copy of her  email alleging that Mexican Fideicomisos may not be foreign trusts and  may  not be required to File Forms 3520 and 3520A. Her email cites a situation where the IRS informally agreed that her client did not have to file Forms 3520/3520A or pay any penalty for not filing. 

We have checked with an IRS representative who directly deals with these issues.  They stated it is very unlikely that in the near future the IRS will ever issue any written ruling or opinion that Fideicomisos do not have to file these foreign trust reporting forms or are not foreign trusts.   

Informal decisions made by the IRS by law cannot be cited as authority by other taxpayers by law. The law also states  written private letter rulings in almost every circumstance cannot be cited as authority by other taxpayers.  Therefore reliance on a privae attorney's written opinion or an informal decision by the IRS can be very risky and will offer no protection in the event you fail to comply with currently accepted IRS filing requirements.  Filing the 3520/3520A form also would be significantly cheaper than going to Court to fight the IRS on this issue when you cannot even cite the informal decision as authority.

Until the IRS (if ever) declares in writing that  Fideicomiso's are exempt from the foreign trust filing requirements or are not foreign trusts, all owners of property in Mexico which hold their title through Fideicomiso's  should continue to file Forms 3520 and 3520A each year to avoid being assessed large monetary penalties by the IRS.

Treasury Inspector General Finds 10% of Foreign Earned Income Exclusions claimed in 2008 Are Invalid or Erroneous

TIGTA Finds Significant Loss in IRS Revenue Because of Erroneously Claimed Foreign Earned Income Tax Exclusions

WASHINGTON - The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) lost an estimated $90 million in revenue for Tax Year 2008 because of erroneously claimed foreign earned income tax exclusions, according to a report publicly released today by the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA).

The foreign earned income tax exclusion allows a taxpayer to exclude up to $91,500 of foreign earned income. A taxpayer qualifies for this exclusion if he or she has foreign income and a home in a foreign country. An eligible taxpayer designates this status by filing Form 2555 (Foreign Earned Income) with the IRS.

TIGTA conducted a performance audit to assess the IRS's ability to ensure the accuracy of these exclusions. TIGTA reviewed 231,277 tax returns from Tax Year 2008 and found that 10 percent (23,334) of taxpayers claiming the exclusion either failed to qualify for the exclusion or inaccurately computed the exclusion. The income erroneously excluded totaled $675 million. The estimated tax avoided totaled $90 million.

"This is very troubling. Over five years, the estimated revenue loss to the IRS could total more than $450 million," said J. Russell George, Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration. "Improvements must be made to reduce erroneously claimed foreign earned income tax exclusions," he added.

TIGTA made seven recommendations to the IRS in this report, and the IRS agreed with four of the seven recommendations.

To review the report, including the scope and methodology, go to: http:www.treas.gov/tigta/auditreports/2010reports/201040091fr.pdf.

New Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) reporting requirements

The new Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) requires that taxpayers report all foreign financial assets if the aggregate current fair market value of all such assets equal $50,000 or more. Foreign financial assets include foreign bank accounts, brokerage accounts, stocks, bonds, and ownership in foreign entities such as foreign corporations, partnerships, trusts, and LLCs.   The IRS has the ability under the new law to define almost any asset located outside the US as a foreign financial assets required to be reported under this law. They will in the future be issuing regulations defining the type of assets they have determined are included under this new law.

These items will either be reported on an attachment to your US tax return or the IRS is most likely to create a new tax form to attach to your return for the reporting. For each such asset you must state full information including account numbers, name and address of financial institution or stock issuer, and the highest value of the foreign asset during the tax year.

If you meet the aggregate $50,000 in value threshold, you will have to report all the information on each asset regardless of the percentage you own or its small value. All other foreign asset reporting forms such as FBARs, Form 5471, 8865, 3520, 3520A, etc must also still be filed if required.

The minimum penalty for failing to report this data begins at $10,000 and can go up from there depending on the circumstances.  This is generally effective for tax years that begin after 3/18/10.

Fideicomiso US Income Taxation Under New 2010 HIRE ACT INVOLVING FOREIGN TRUSTS

A widely distributed article recently published by some attorneys contains some dire warnings about the  adverse income tax  consequences of the new foreign trust provisions in the HIRE-FATCA Act passed early in 2010 with respect to Fideicomisos (which the IRS currently requires file Forms 3520 and 3520A  because the IRS currently holds Fideicomisos  to be foreign trusts).  The conclusions in this article are  most likely not correct if the Fideicomiso has no income and contains property held for investment or held for personal use by the beneficiary (not a rental property). The IRS has not at this time ( nor is it likely to  in the near future)  issued any regulations further explaining the effect of the provisions of the new law on Fideicomisos and foreign trusts.  What the regulations or further guidance may say is pure speculation.  The general principles of trust taxation which are most likely to apply are stated in the next paragraph.

Under general trust tax law involving income and distributions from trusts to beneficiaries, unless the trust generates taxable income, the mere fact that personal use of foreign trust real property by a beneficiary is treated as a distribution to that beneficiary, will not cause the personal use to be taxed to the owner or beneficiary of the Fideicomiso because distributions from trusts are only taxable to the extent of the trusts DNI (Distributable Net Income).

You must keep in mind that  until the IRS issues further guidance and regulations on this new law, you cannot be certain they will not "twist" its interpretation of the new changes in a manner which is not consistent with prior long standing us trust tax principles. Therefore some uncertainty will exist until then.

TDF 90-22.1 FOREIGN FINANCIAL ACCOUNT REPORT DUE 6/30/10 - STREET ADDRESS TO USE FOR DHL, FED EXP OR UPS DELIVERY

The following street address should be used to file TDF 90-22.1 (FBAR) form when the US mail is not available for delivery. These private delivery services will not deliver to the PO Box shown delivery address shown on the form's instructions.:

IRS Detroit Computing Center
Attn: FBAR Mailroom
4th Floor
985 Michigan Ave.
Detroit, MI 48226
(313) 234-1062



This form must be filed immediately. If it does not arrive by 6/30/10, you may incur a $10,000 late filing penalty. The fine can be greater if you do not file at all and also might include criminal prosecution.  When in doubt whether you owe the form to the US Treasury, best to file just to be certain there are no problems since it does not cause any additional income tax cost, and is only a reporting form.

Due Date of FBAR Filing Fast Approaching

The deadline for filing Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts,Form TD F 90-22.1 (FBAR) for calendar 2009 is fast approaching. These reports are due by June 30th each year. Unlike the rule for tax forms, FBAR must be received by Treasury on or before the June 30th date to be considered timely filed. Therefore, one should plan accordingly and file the FBAR in sufficient time in advance of the due date. No extension of time to file is permitted.

Penalties can be severe. Persons who are required to file the FBAR and who do not do so by June 30th are subject to a penalty. For a willful violation the penalty can be as high as the greater of $100,000 or 50% of the amount in the foreign account. For a nonwillful violation that is not corrected and for which there is no reasonable cause, the penalty can be as high as $10,000.

Several IRS pronouncements should be considered when working on 2009 FBARs, including Announcement 2010-16 and Notice 2010-23. You can link directly to

FAST US INCOME TAX FACTS FOR AMERICANS LIVING AND WORKING IN MEXICO

· If you are a US Citizen you must file a US tax return every year unless your income is less than $ 9,350  (for 2009 and lower for earlier years) or have self employment-independent contractor  net income of more than $  400 US per year.  You are taxable on your world wide income regardless of whether you filed a tax return in Mexico.



· As an US expatriate living in Mexico on 4/15, your 2009 tax  return is automatically extended until 6/15 but any taxes due must be paid by 4/15 to avoid penalties.  The return can be further extended until 10/15/10 if the proper extension is filed.


· For 2009 if you are a qualified expatriate you get a foreign earned income exclusion (earnings from wages or self employment) of $91,400, but this exclusion is only available if you file a tax return.

· If your spouse works and lives abroad, and is qualified, she can also get at $91,400 foreign earned income exclusion.


· You get credits against your US income tax obligation for taxes paid to foreign country but you must file a return to claim these credits.


· If you own 10% or more of a Mexican corporation or hold an interest in Mexican property through a Fideicomiso you must file special IRS forms each year or incur substantial penalties which can be greater including criminal prosecution if the IRS discovers you have failed to file these forms.


· Your net self employment income in Mexico is subject to US self employment tax of 15.3% (social security) which cannot be reduced or eliminated by the foreign earned income exclusion.


· Forming the correct type of Mexican corporation and making the property US tax elections with respect to that corporation can save you a significant amount of US income taxes.

· If at any time during the tax year your combined highest balances in your Mexican bank and financial accounts (when added together) ever equal or exceed $10,000US you must file a FBAR form with the IRS by June 30th for the prior calendar year or incur a penalty of $10,000 or more including criminal prosecution. This form does not go in with your personal income tax return and is filed separately at a separate address.
· We understand the Mexican income tax laws and can coordinate your US taxes with those you pay in Mexico to help you achieve the optimum tax strategy.


· In the past year the IRS has hired more than 800 new employees to audit, investigate and discover Americans living abroad who have failed to file all necessary tax forms.


· Often due to foreign tax credits and the the foreign earned income exclusion expats living in Mexico and file all past year unfiled tax returns and end up owing no or very little US taxes.


· Beginning in 2010 a new law is in effect which requires all US Citizens report all of their world wife financial assets if in total the value of those assets are $50,000 or more.


· Income from certain types of foreign corporations are immediately taxable on the US shareholder's personal income tax return.


· If you own investments in a foreign corporation or own foreign mutual fund shares you may be required to file the IRS forms for owning part of a Passive Foreign Investment Company (PFIC) or incur additional, taxes and penalties for your failure to do so. A PFIC is any foreign corporation that has more than 75% of its gross income from passive income or 50 percent or more of its assets produce or will produce passive income.


· The IRS is now matching up your US passport with your US tax records and now knows if  you  have not been filing all required US tax returns while you are living  in Mexico.


· Download your 2009 US tax return questionnaire drafted expressly for Americans living in Mexico at  http://www.taxmeless.com/07_Expat_Questionnaire__v2.doc